In the video, Paul discusses the AI mastering platform Dictatorial, showcasing its ability to master tracks using text prompts and providing instant feedback, which highlights its speed and convenience compared to traditional services. However, he raises concerns about the quality of the AI’s output and the potential impact on the job market for human engineers, suggesting that while Dictatorial is a promising tool for beginners, it still requires improvements to match professional standards.
In the video, Paul, the host, introduces the concept of AI mastering, specifically focusing on a platform called Dictatorial. He describes his recent experiences with immersive audio in Switzerland but shifts the topic to discuss the advancements in AI technology in music production. The main feature of Dictatorial is its ability to not only master tracks automatically but also to communicate using text prompts, mimicking the interaction one would have with a human mastering engineer. This unique characteristic makes it stand out in the rapidly evolving AI music landscape.
Paul demonstrates the capabilities of Dictatorial by uploading a track from an animated series. He emphasizes the importance of avoiding clipping and distortion during mixing and notes that the AI can take simple prompts to adjust various audio parameters. Throughout the video, he tests the AI’s responsiveness to his commands, experimenting with different styles and characteristics he desires in the final master, such as warmth, loudness, and stereo width. The instant feedback from the AI is highlighted as a significant advantage over traditional mastering services, which often require longer turnaround times.
As Paul continues to compare the results from Dictatorial against his own manual mastering, he evaluates the AI’s performance in terms of loudness, dynamics, and overall sound quality. He notes that while the AI provides a reasonable master, it lacks the brightness and boldness he was hoping for, indicating some limitations in its capabilities. This leads him to conclude that while the AI is impressive for its speed and convenience, it may not yet fully meet the expectations of professional audio engineers, particularly in achieving the desired sound profile.
Paul raises concerns about the potential implications of AI mastering on the job market for human engineers. He expresses his apprehension regarding the unchecked development of AI technologies, fearing that they could displace skilled professionals in the industry. Despite acknowledging the benefits of using AI, particularly for those without experience or resources, he warns against the rapid and uncontrolled proliferation of such technologies that could undermine the quality and integrity of music mastering.
In conclusion, Paul finds Dictatorial to be a fascinating tool with significant potential, particularly for novice users. However, he emphasizes that improvements are needed in the AI’s responsiveness and decision-making to make it a truly effective alternative to human mastering. He encourages viewers to share their thoughts on AI developments in music and concludes the video with a note of caution regarding the future of AI in the industry.