In the video, Paul reviews ACE Studio, an AI singing software that offers over 80 customizable AI-generated vocalists, while expressing skepticism about its ethical implications and potential impact on human vocalists. Despite acknowledging the software’s technological achievements, he ultimately finds it unsatisfactory for commercial use, emphasizing the irreplaceable value of human expression and collaboration in music.
In the video, Paul introduces his review of ACE Studio, an AI singing software that aims to assist music producers by providing artificial vocalists. He shares that the company reached out to him due to his influence on YouTube and expressed their desire for him to review their platform. Paul, who has previously voiced skepticism about AI in music, agrees to give ACE Studio a try while emphasizing that his review will be independent and honest. He sets the stage for a critical examination of the software’s capabilities and its implications for human vocalists.
Paul begins by exploring the ACE Studio website and its features, noting that it offers over 80 AI-generated singers with customizable voices. He highlights the software’s ability to create demos quickly, providing harmonies and backing vocals. However, he expresses concern about the ethical implications of using AI to replace human vocalists, questioning whether the technology truly empowers music producers or undermines the livelihoods of real singers. Despite the software’s impressive technological execution, he remains wary of its potential impact on the music industry.
As Paul tests the software, he demonstrates how to input melodies and lyrics, noting that the AI can accurately match syllables to notes. However, he quickly encounters issues with the AI’s vocal output, describing it as heavily autotuned and lacking in emotional depth. He points out pronunciation problems and inconsistencies in note lengths, which detract from the overall quality of the performance. Despite the software’s user-friendly interface, he finds the editing process tedious and time-consuming, leading him to question its practicality for serious music production.
Throughout the review, Paul emphasizes his preference for working with human vocalists, arguing that the emotional connection and creativity that come from collaborating with real people cannot be replicated by AI. He expresses concern about the broader implications of AI in the music industry, particularly the potential for job loss among vocalists. Paul reflects on the decline in contracts for voiceover artists due to AI advancements, voicing his hope that similar trends do not occur in the realm of singing.
In conclusion, Paul delivers a mixed review of ACE Studio, acknowledging its technological achievements while ultimately deeming it unsatisfactory for commercial use. He reiterates his belief that AI should not replace human artists, as the essence of music lies in human expression and collaboration. While he appreciates the software’s capabilities for drafting ideas, he firmly advocates for the continued importance of human vocalists in the music industry, expressing a desire to see the technology remain limited in its development.